John Roberts: The Nominee (NY Review of Books)

The most intriguing question about John Roberts is what led him as a young person whose success in life was virtually assured by family wealth and academic achievement to enlist in a political campaign designed to deny opportunities for success to those who lacked his advantages. It is a question of great relevance to Roberts’s candidacy for the Supreme Court. As the late Charles Black has written, no serious person is under the illusion that “a judge’s judicial work is not influenced…by his sense, sharp or vague, of where justice lies in respect to the great issues of his time.”

After a privileged upbringing in an Indiana suburb, attendance at an exclusive, expensive private school, high ranking at the undergraduate and law schools of Harvard, and clerkships with Federal Appeals Judge Henry Friendly and Supreme Court Justice William Rehnquist, John Roberts took a job in the Reagan administration. There he joined in its efforts to dismantle the civil rights gains of the 1960s and 1970s. His work as a young man in the 1980s established the pattern of his later public career. (more…)

Advertisements